Helping Colorado’s accident
victims for over 25 years.

Denver Underinsured Driver Accident Attorney

Scott O’Sullivan knows that learning the other driver has insurance can feel reassuring at first. Then the insurer discloses the policy limits, and you realize that the available coverage may not come close to paying for your injuries.

A driver can carry legally required insurance and still leave an injured person facing substantial unpaid losses. Surgery, rehabilitation, time away from work, and lasting physical limitations can quickly exceed a minimum-limit policy.

Scott has represented injured Coloradans since 1996 and previously defended insurance companies and corporations. He uses that experience to examine available coverage, evaluate disputed losses, and help clients understand what additional recovery may be possible.

If the driver who injured you does not have enough insurance, call The O’Sullivan Law Firm at (303) 388-5304 or contact us online. A free consultation with a Denver underinsured driver accident lawyer can help you assess the gap between the available liability coverage and the harm you suffered.

When Having Insurance Still Leaves Someone Underprotected

Scott’s coverage review distinguishes between a driver who has no applicable insurance and one whose insurance is insufficient. Those situations can lead to different claims, even though uninsured and underinsured motorist protection are often discussed together.

An uninsured driver lacks applicable liability coverage. An underinsured driver has coverage, but the available bodily injury limits do not fully compensate the injured person for legally recoverable damages.

Colorado generally requires automobile liability coverage of at least:

  • $25,000 per person for bodily injury.
  • $50,000 per accident for bodily injury.
  • $15,000 per accident for property damage.

The bodily injury and property damage limits serve different purposes. Unused property damage coverage ordinarily cannot simply be transferred to pay an injury claim.

For someone seriously hurt in a collision on I-25, $25,000 may be inadequate before the full extent of recovery is known. The other driver’s legal compliance does not mean their policy will cover your losses.

Colorado’s Underinsurance Problem Deserves Attention

Scott’s focus on coverage reflects a problem that extends beyond an occasional minimum-limit policy. Insurance industry research identifies substantial underinsurance exposure in Colorado.

The Insurance Research Council’s estimates, published by the Insurance Information Institute, show:

  • Colorado’s estimated underinsured motorist rate reached 49.7% in 2023, the highest state rate reported.
  • The Council previously reported a 40.9% Colorado underinsured motorist rate for 2022.
  • Colorado’s estimated rate increased by 24.4 percentage points between 2017 and 2023, according to the Council’s later report.

These research estimates come from insurance claim frequencies, not a direct census of every driver’s policy. They still show why an injury claim may require more than confirming the other driver was insured.

Scott reviews the actual coverage and damages in your case. Statewide estimates cannot determine whether a particular driver’s insurance is sufficient.

How Underinsured Motorist Coverage Can Help

Scott examines your own insurance when the at-fault driver’s bodily injury limits appear inadequate. Underinsured motorist coverage, commonly called UIM coverage, may provide additional compensation for covered injury losses.

In Colorado, UIM coverage generally addresses legally recoverable bodily injury damages exceeding the applicable liability limits, up to the available UIM limit. It does not automatically pay its full limit simply because the other driver had less insurance.

You still need evidence of the other driver’s responsibility and the amount of your damages. Coverage eligibility, policy terms, and applicable law also matter.

Potential covered losses may include medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering. The bodily injury portion of UIM coverage does not pay to repair your vehicle.

An Example of How the Coverage Gap Works

Scott uses the actual policy limits and supported damages to explain potential recovery. A hypothetical example can help illustrate the distinction.

Suppose your legally recoverable injury damages are $150,000, the at-fault driver has $25,000 in applicable bodily injury liability coverage, and you have $100,000 in available UIM coverage. Depending on the facts and coverage requirements, the liability policy could pay $25,000, and the UIM policy could provide up to another $100,000.

That would still leave some damages uncompensated. The UIM limit is a ceiling on that coverage, not a promise that every loss will be paid.

If the damages were lower, the potential UIM payment would also be lower. Scott evaluates the claim rather than treating the policy limit as the settlement value.

Do You Have UIM Coverage if You Never Specifically Requested It?

Scott’s policy review includes how coverage was selected or rejected. Many people know their monthly premium but cannot recall whether they accepted uninsured and underinsured motorist protection.

Colorado generally requires applicable automobile liability policies to include UM/UIM protection unless the named insured rejects it in writing. Insurers must also offer the opportunity to obtain coverage equal to the policy’s bodily injury liability limits, subject to statutory requirements and exceptions.

Your declarations page is a useful starting point, but the full policy and relevant selection or rejection documents may also need review. Do not assume coverage is absent because you do not remember discussing it.

Scott can examine:

  • The policy in effect on the collision date.
  • Listed UM/UIM limits.
  • Definitions of insured persons.
  • Coverage endorsements and exclusions.
  • Written rejection or selection documents.
  • Other potentially applicable policies.

The answer should come from the documents and the law, not a guess about what you purchased.

 Underinsured Driver Accident

Coverage May Extend Beyond the Car You Were Driving

Scott looks at insured status as well as vehicle ownership. Depending on policy language and the circumstances, potential coverage may come from more than one source.

A person injured while riding as a passenger may have coverage under the occupied vehicle’s policy and potentially another policy. A resident family member’s coverage may also require examination.

UIM protection can sometimes apply to an insured person injured while walking or riding a bicycle. Being outside your own car does not automatically eliminate coverage.

A collision near Union Station, a bicycle injury on Speer Boulevard, or a passenger injury during a trip through Cherry Creek may therefore raise different coverage questions. Scott reviews the circumstances without assuming that only the driver’s personal policy matters.

Can Multiple UIM Policies Be Combined?

Scott evaluates each potentially applicable policy because combining coverage requires more than adding the limits listed on declarations pages. Colorado law and the policy structure determine what coverage is available.

Separate policies may present different issues from a single policy covering several vehicles. A policy issued for one premium covering multiple vehicles may limit UM/UIM coverage to applying once per accident.

Do not assume every listed vehicle creates another available limit. Scott can assess the policies, insured status, and applicable restrictions.

Why Settling With the Other Driver Requires Care

Scott reviews proposed liability settlements before clients sign because accepting payment can affect the remaining claim. A release may resolve rights against the driver and other parties, while the UIM policy may contain relevant notice or settlement provisions.

The sequence of the claims deserves attention. Accepting less than the available liability limit can create an uncompensated gap that the UIM insurer may not be required to fill.

Before resolving the liability claim, important questions include:

  • Whether all applicable liability policies have been identified.
  • Whether the offered amount represents the available limit.
  • Whether other parties may share responsibility.
  • Whether the UIM insurer needs notice or other action.
  • Whether the release affects claims you intend to preserve.
  • Whether the injuries and future losses have been adequately evaluated.

Scott can assess those issues before a payment becomes a binding settlement. An offer described as “all the insurance available” should be verified.

Your Own Insurer May Dispute the Value of the Claim

Scott’s insurance-defense experience informs his approach when the UIM insurer challenges damages. Although you are seeking benefits under your own policy, the company may disagree about what it owes.

Disputes can concern whether treatment was necessary, whether symptoms resulted from the collision, how much work you missed, or whether future care is supported. The insurer may also question fault or eligibility for coverage.

Scott addresses those issues through evidence rather than assuming that an existing customer relationship guarantees payment.

Depending on the dispute, supporting material may include:

  • Medical records and treatment recommendations.
  • Employment and wage records.
  • Evidence of previous health and functioning.
  • Photographs and witness statements.
  • Collision investigation records.
  • Professional assessments of future care or earning losses.

A disagreement does not automatically establish insurer bad faith. Unreasonable delay or denial may raise separate legal issues, which require their own factual assessment.

Scott Documents the Losses That Continue After Treatment Begins

Scott evaluates an underinsured driver claim with attention to the person’s future, rather than stopping at the first collection of bills. A serious injury can affect work and independence long after emergency treatment ends.

A construction worker injured near the I-70 corridor may struggle to return to physically demanding employment. An office employee rear-ended on Colorado Boulevard may lose work time because of persistent headaches or restricted movement.

Depending on the evidence, recoverable injury damages may include:

  • Hospital and emergency care.
  • Surgery and rehabilitation.
  • Future medical treatment.
  • Prescription medication and medical equipment.
  • Lost wages.
  • Reduced earning capacity.
  • Necessary assistance with daily activities.
  • Pain and suffering.
  • Loss of enjoyment of life.
  • Permanent impairment or disfigurement.

Available damages remain subject to applicable law and limits. Scott can explain which losses are supported and what additional documentation may be needed.

Medical Bills and Vehicle Repairs Use Different Coverage

Scott separates the available coverages so clients understand why one payment may not resolve another part of the claim. Health insurance, medical payments coverage, collision coverage, and UIM protection serve different functions.

MedPay may help pay covered medical expenses regardless of fault, subject to its limits and terms. Health insurance may also assist with treatment, although deductibles, copayments, and reimbursement issues can arise.

Collision coverage may address damage to your vehicle. UIM bodily injury coverage addresses qualifying injury damages rather than the repair bill.

Payments from other sources can create coordination or reimbursement questions. Scott reviews those issues when assessing both the claim and the amount ultimately available to the client.

What if Several People Were Injured?

Scott examines per-person and per-accident limits when a collision injures multiple people. A policy with a $25,000 per-person limit and a $50,000 per-accident limit does not provide $25,000 to every injured person regardless of the number of claims.

Several serious injuries can exhaust the shared accident limit. This can happen in a multi-vehicle collision near the I-25 and I-70 interchange or when several occupants are hurt in one car.

Careful review is needed to determine how liability proceeds are distributed and how UIM coverage responds. The analysis should account for the applicable limits, other claims, and each injured person’s policies.

Scott can evaluate those circumstances rather than assuming the amount available to one person matches the policy’s advertised maximum.

Is Suing the Driver Personally an Option?

Scott considers other recovery sources when insurance is inadequate, but suing the driver requires a practical assessment. A judgment does not guarantee you can collect.

The driver’s assets, applicable exemptions, and other circumstances may affect recovery. Litigation expenses and the likely outcome also matter.

Other responsible parties may deserve investigation. If the driver was working or another person’s negligence contributed, additional liability coverage might exist.

Scott evaluates supported possibilities. He does not assume that insufficient insurance means a personal lawsuit is either necessary or worthwhile.

UIM Claims Have Their Own Deadline Rules

Scott identifies deadlines for both the underlying injury claim and the insurance claim. Colorado motor vehicle injury lawsuits generally have a three-year filing period, but UIM actions follow specific statutory provisions.

Those provisions include circumstances allowing an action within two years after payment of an underlying liability settlement or judgment when the underlying claim was timely preserved. How that rule applies depends on the claim’s sequence and facts.

Policy notice and cooperation obligations also require attention. Negotiations with either insurer do not necessarily preserve the right to file suit.

Scott can determine the relevant deadlines early. If litigation is necessary, jurisdiction and venue will determine the appropriate court, which may include Denver District Court at the City and County Building on Bannock Street.

Let Scott Review the Coverage Before You Accept the Shortfall

Scott O’Sullivan understands that discovering insufficient insurance can make an already difficult recovery feel more uncertain. You should have a clear explanation of what the other driver’s policy provides, whether your own coverage can help, and what evidence is needed.

The O’Sullivan Law Firm provides direct attorney access and free consultations. We offer injury representation on a contingency fee basis under the representation agreement, and you owe attorney fees only if we recover compensation, as outlined in that agreement.

Call (303) 388-5304 or contact us online for a review with a Denver underinsured driver accident attorney. Bring the insurance information and correspondence you have so Scott can assess the options beyond the other driver’s policy limits.


Free Consultation

  • All fields required
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.